When Should You Choose Stump Removal Over Grinding?

Understanding the Differences Between Removing  a Stump and Grinding It

Stump removal refers to removing the whole stump and the root system of the tree completely, so that you are ready to begin your landscaping again. All parts of the tree (including the underground root system) will be removed completely when using this method. On the other hand, stump grinding is the process of using a special machine to grind/chip the part of the stump that is above ground into small pieces until the stump is usually ground down approximately 1 to 2 inches below the surface of the ground, but leaves the root system intact.

The decision to choose one method versus the other, ultimately, will depend on how you plan to use the area long-term. Areas such as those around Prospect Hill and Assembly Row that already contain developed landscaping may need to take a different approach to the removal of stumps versus brand-new construction projects in Spring Hill.

When To Choose Complete Stump Removal

Construction and Development Project Needs

If you are going to be building a deck, installing a swimming pool, or constructing an addition to your house near Union Square, complete stump removal is the only way to go. When you remove the stump by grinding it, the roots of the original tree can cause problems when you begin your construction project and install the necessary utilities and foundations. The compact size of most of Somerville’s residential lots, particularly in some of the older neighborhoods such as Magoun Square, means that homeowners looking to expand their living space through construction will need to maximize every inch of available space.

Avoiding Problems Down The Road

When you leave the roots of the original tree behind after grinding the stump, the roots can grow further and cause problems with sidewalks, driveways, and the underground utilities. This is a particular concern in Somerville’s older neighborhoods (such as Winter Hill) that were built many years ago and have narrow streets and little available space for expansion.

Planting A New Tree In The Same Spot

If you wish to replant a new tree in the same location as the previous one, stump removal will give you the best possible base upon which to start. As the new tree grows and develops, it will be able to draw the necessary water and nutrients from the ground without being impacted by the remnants of the old root system. This is an ideal solution for homeowners in East Somerville who wish to maintain the tree canopy on their property while removing older or diseased trees.

Why Choose Stump Grinding

Low Cost Solutions

Stump grinding generally costs less money than complete stump removal. Stump grinding also requires much less labor and equipment to complete. Homeowners in Teele Square or Ball Square who are working within a budget find that grinding provides an affordable solution to remove the stump and prevent damage to the rest of the landscaping/hardscape.

Least Amount Of Landscaping Disturbance

Grinding causes minimal disturbance to the surrounding landscaping and hardscape. If you have established gardens, walkways, or decorative elements around the stump, grinding will preserve these elements and allow you to immediately address the problem.

Benefits Of Natural Decomposition

The ground-up wood chips that result from grinding the stump can be used as a natural mulch and can add nutrient-rich material to the soil as they break down over time. Using these wood chips as mulch can improve the overall health and structure of the soil and provide nutrients for the plants that surround the stump. These are just two examples of why eco-friendly residents throughout Somerville would choose grinding to remove the stump from their property.

Specific Factors That Apply To Somerville Properties

Local Municipal Regulations And Permits

Somerville has its own set of municipal regulations regarding the removal of trees from both public and private property. Before performing either stump grinding or stump removal, you should check with your local government to see if there are any permits required to perform the work you plan to do. Some of the regulations that apply to certain areas of Somerville include restrictions on doing work to trees located near public spaces or within designated historic districts (Powder House Square).

Soil Conditions And Water Drainage Patterns

Somerville’s geography varies from high-elevation areas near Prospect Hill to low-lying areas closer to the Mystic River. Therefore, the soil conditions and drainage patterns vary widely across the city. Complete stump removal in areas with poor drainage could lead to standing-water problems; however, grinding allows for easier management of water in these types of locations.

Property Space Requirements

Many of Somerville’s residential properties are situated on small parcels of land that offer very little room between each house. Neighborhoods such as Inner Belt or Ward Two have homes that sit very closely together; therefore, the ability to bring in heavy equipment to remove the stump may limit the homeowner to choosing to grind out the stump.

Making The Best Choice For Your Property

Somerville Tree Masters understands the unique challenges that face property owners in the Somerville community. Whether you live in the historic neighborhoods surrounding Davis Square or in one of the newer developments in Assembly Row, our experienced team of professionals has assisted numerous residents in making informed decisions concerning their tree-care needs. We will come to your property, discuss your options, and then provide professional stump removal or grinding service to meet your needs and budget.